
I baked cinnamon rolls from scratch for the very first time over the holidays, something I have been wanting to do for a very long time. I used Alton Brown's 'overnight' recipe that calls for preparing them the day before and baking them off in the morning. I loved the comforting feeling upon waking up and having them there waiting for me to pop into the oven. Such convenience. And then to have the entire house fill with that welcoming smell of cinnamon dough was blissful.
But in all honesty I wasn't 'wowed' by them the way I wanted to be. The roll itself was kind of bland - even after I had doctored it up by adding Cinnamon right into the raw dough. If you know me - you know I have a hard time following a recipe exactly as written. I also added chopped walnuts to the filling which was a delicious touch and doubled the icing recipe also adding more cinnamon (because you can never have too much of a good thing) and a dash of vanilla.
I was looking for something extra special; something to impress; and these failed to do that for me. Don't get me wrong I wouldn't refuse one if offered. They weren't terrible tasting or anything, but I won't make them again. They did solicit "oohs" and "mmms" from family members. And I'm happy because I can finally cross them off that long 'to do' list of mine...

My changes:
-Add one teaspoon of Cinnamon to the dough at the beginning along with the butter and eggs.
-Sprinkle a cup of chopped walnuts over the cinnamon filling before rolling up.
-Add a 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon and a dash of vanilla to the icing. Double the icing recipe if you like a lot like I do!

I have to give a shout-out and a thank-you to the generous people over at Red Ape Cinnamon who sent me this cute little jar of cinnamon to try out. I have been using it in everything (they don't call me Cinnamon Girl for nothing) sprinkling it in my hot tea, oatmeal, and Greek yogurt. I used it for all my holiday baking including my Butterscotch Blondies. Red Ape Cinnamon is a robust Korintje cinnamon from Sumatra and is sustainably harvested from Cassia Cinnamon trees that are at least 20 years old. The Volatile Oil (V.O.) content is much higher in older trees resulting in a higher quality cinnamon. The best part is that 5% of profits from sales of their cinnamon is donated to programs dedicated to the protection and restoration of orangutan (a.k.a. The Red Ape) habitat in Indonesia.

77 comments:
If you got mmms from your family is an excellent signal of a tasty dessert...these rolls are superb, is there a limit to cinnamon in sweets? - I guess not :)
Cheers,
Gera
These look incredible. Thanks so much for sharing them. We're having a sleepover for high school-aged girls here next weekend and I needed something to make them for breakfast. These will be awesome!
~Amanda
http://jayhawkgirlskitchen.blogspot.com
They look pretty darn awesome!
I think all cinnamon roll dough is generally bland. It's the topping and filling that makes them, in my opinion. But if your family liked them, chalk one up for you. The photos are so wonderful, it's hard to imagine they were so so.
Oh man, those look wicked good. I'll have to find an excuse to make some!
they look fab! totally a breakfast perfection!
I am immediately sending this to my daughter. She's been talking about making Cinnamon Rolls from scratch, forever!!!
If hers come out any where near as gorgeous as yours, I may just have to move to Idaho!!! Incredible, Reeni and great tips and info. Thanks for sharing...
i have actually had that same thing with many cinnamon roll recipes. i have never found one that I adore, though I did one with cinnamon, cardamon and golden raisin filling that was alright.
I received some of that cinnamon, too several months back. I really love the taste of it. As for those cinnamon rolls. i don't know if I can wait overnight, but then again it's from Alton Brown, so I can I can give it a shot.
I so appreciate your honest rewview. I really love the concept of the overnight cinnamon roll, I bet you can create one that would be worthy! If anyone can, it's you!!
So much cinnamon-y goodness! These sound amazing!!! Desserts made from scratch are always the best, even if these didn't turn out quite as planned. :)
xxoo
Heather
ooh, i'll must take the icing, please :)
delicious looking! It's bliss to enjoy freshly baked goodies in the morning :)
I am seriously contemplating mixing a batch of these up right now to enjoy tomorrow AM. Unfortunately, I promised the hubs I would make him some pancakes tomorrow. I suppose they'll have to wait until Saturday!
Well even if they did not taste like you thought they should, they turned out beautiful!!!
I found that a recipe I used was bland too.
Nothing a little more salt,sugar and butter can't fix! :)
Mmmmm! My husband makes cinnamon rolls but he hasn't tried any overnight ones. I'll be sure to show him these though cause I want to try them!
Hugs to Moon!
The cinnamon looks fantastic, sorry that it doesn't meet expectations.
Wow, now that's some beautiful rolls!!!!!
They sure do look awesome! I wish I had some right now :) I'm sorry they didn't wow you (I usually find AB recipes to be great) but I'm sure a few tweaks will make it perfect :)
You seem to know all my weakness and push my buttons. Thank goodness there is no scent along with your posts, because if I caught just the hint of cinnamon it would have been all over!
OOOOOOOOooooohj they looks fabulous...
Sorry to hear your cinnamon rolls were disappointing to you. Do you normally like cinnamon rolls? I am a huge fan. I would likely eat them every day if that wouldn't lead to me weighing three hundred pounds! lol They sure look beautiful, and I saw that episode where he made them. Generally, the dough doesn't seem to have much going for it flavor wise. It's the texture that always matters to me along with the cinnamon filling and the icing. I'm pretty sure I would have been oohing and ahhing right along with your family.
Even though you say they were bland, they look delicious. I wanted to dive right into the frosting of your first picture!
There is a recipe for Cinnamon Rolls in the Pioneer Woman Cookbook that I've been meaning to try. You have inspired me to do so this weekend!
Wow! Is this your own recipe? Man, it makes me drooled.
i must say... the words "overnight" made my ears perk up (moreso than usual) for this post! i love having something made from scratch, just ready to go the next day! soooooooo nice to be able to just bake off and enjoy! sorry they weren't what you wanted them to be... i sure know how that feels. but it does look finger-licking good... especially with that icing! MMMMM!
I remember seeing this episode of Good Eats and absolutely drooling. They looked like a lot of work, and I was intimidated, but I loved how they looked (and how I imagined they tasted). They look divine. I can tell you did the recipe justice even if it didn't live up to your expectations.
Awesome job on these, and very droolworthy pictures!
*kisses* HH
Sorry you were disappointed by your cinnamon rolls, they look spectacular.
Mimi
They look fabulous though so maybe you are just being too hard on yourself. I wish they would turn out as good for me :(
I hate it when things fail to satisfy my expectations. But if it's a consolation, they do look marvellous.
I've checked the recipe, and wow, that's a whole lot of eggs in the dough, the one I'm using is without eggs, and still it tastes great (last time I made them, I sweeped half a pan within few hours ;)))
Well, they LOOK incredible. Maybe making a cardamom-flavored dough (like for my Swedish tea ring) would give them an extra kick, as it would contrast with the cinnamon?
I would definitely take one anyday though!
Kind of relieved to hear you weren't that impressed with these...they LOOK fantastic, and I am trying to avoid temptations like this at the moment. Somehow knowing you weren't crazy about them makes them a bit easier to resist.
Happy new year!
These are great party rolls! Actually I think these cuties are fit for any occasions. They could even make your mother-in-law smile with satisfaction!
Cinnamon roll looks awesome Cinnamon girl...Mouthwatering pic,will surely try...
Cinnamon rolls are on my to do list too and I reckon that mmms and oohs aren't a bad result, even if you weren't blown away by them :)
Those look amazing ... and perfect for a snowy morning.
I am comming over to your place in the morning newt time when you make these delcious rolls.
This is the ultimate cinnamon rolls!
I have 5 girls spending the night tonight and this might be a great treat to make up tonight. I wish you had been more impressed with them but you've inspired me to make some rolls for them!
Love the plate! I have also been wanting to make cinnamon rolls from scratch. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the taste of Alton Brown's recipe. They do look delicious!!!
bummer they weren't as amazing as they look, because MAN they look delicious!
Expectations are tough! But wow do they look delicious and soemthing I would love to wake up to on a frigid Minnesota morning!
Sorry to hear you weren't immediately wowed by these. I made them for a bake sale a couple of years ago and actually quite enjoyed them, but I agree that a little extra something something always helps dough. I think next time I might do a little grated orange peel as I think it goes quite nicely with cinnamon.
I have a brioche bun recipe that I use for my sticky buns which is packed with flavor, but they are also tremendously rich and fatty.
I do thoguh think that as cooks we are often our most judgemental critics. I can seem to pick apart any dish I make only to get rave reviews from others.
They sure look good to me....Ever had a cinnabon? OMG!!!
I love you for your honest review!!! I think I'll try a different recipe when I make them cuz like you I want to be wowed.
I like that you can do all the prep work the night before for these. I'm sorry that these were not quite what you were looking for but they do look very yummy!
I'm sorry you were disappointed in these. They look gorgeous anyways! There's a recipe in The Art and Soul of Baking for these that I plan to try at some point. I'll let you know if it's any good.
I'm so glad you tested these for me. I was wondering if I should try these, and you made up my mind for me!
Sorry they weren't as good as they look.
well they look absolutely mouthwatering, but i'm sorry they didn't turn out quite how you would have like them.
Reeni Those Look EXCELLENT !
I put vanilla puddin mix and also vanilla extract in. that's what adds that missing dimension of flavor. this makes them more like the cinnabon taste. I make a sweetdough with the additional ingredients - in the breadmachine; put it into a plastic bag in the fridge overnite to flavor and coldproof. that seems to make the difference for me. I also use the same egg/challa dough to base my pecan cinnamon rolls. the same dough is also used in my monkey bread. I made croissants for the third time this week lastnite. this time hubby left me one. ;]
Sorry they didn't come out to suit you, that happens to me too. We have high expectations even when our fam ooohs and aaahs. But they do look outrageously good.
Nice job on your cinnamon rolls! I have yet to try making them. Oh and I am dying to try that cinnamon!
hey ..thanks so much for the recipe..these are my favorites and eat them everytime i see a cinnabon outlet
I'm just happy if mine rise correctly. These look delicious!!!
Sorry these were a little disappointing! I love your addition of walnuts though, and I definitely like extra icing on my cinnamon rolls! :)
These are to die for! Bookmarked! I eat these for dessert and breakfast and snack & load my car with the cinnamon rolls from IKEA :-) Perfectly done Reeni.
I literally gasped when I saw the photo! They came out wonderful, I'm sorry to hear that they did not come out the way you wanted but that's what recipes are about tweaking them according to your tastes :)
now after seeing your yummy cinnamon rolls I have the urge to bake some
Even though you weren't happy with the final product, they look delicious!
Reeni, you are precious for your honesty and guts to try something new! We love cinnamon rolls around here and one day I'll post a good one from a former colleague of mine who was kind enough to share it with me. I'll still try this recipe anyway! I love all of your tips and your writing has blossomed by getting so wonderfully interesting and descriptive....just love it! Roz
They look so decedent, gooey and delicious to me! Yum!
This is onmy list too! I really should make this soon! So good!
Dear Reeni,
Cinnamon rolls are one of my favorite delights! These look great! Blessings to you, Catherine
Reeni, Sorry they didn't wow you, but they look fabulous. If you want more of a bang, try making a dried fruit/nut filling instead of just nuts. It makes a difference.
I made overnight cinn. rolls for Christmas breakie and the filling seemed to melt out in the fridge.
Haven't tried Alton's yet though. They do look tasty.
These look wonderful...eventhough you say they were a bit bland, I think that icing would make up for that. :)
Reeni, these look good to me!! I wouldn't turn one down that's for sure. Well done.
Ok! It's official! I'm giving all my kids up for adoption and moving in with you, LOL!
Dear Cinnamon,
Your blog was exceptional. Enjoyed it very much and will be sure to return for another bite!
Thank you for sharing,
Cheers,
PT,
You can visit me at: http://ptsaldari.posterous.com/
Bummer that they weren't quite up to par. I've made a few cinnamon roll recipes now and really think I prefer the no yeast one. Crazy, right? But it was sooo good AND easy! Like you though I wouldn't pass up one of your cinnamon rolls and certainly NOT with double glaze! :)
~ingrid
I just want to stay here and gape at those photos. Please, please let me.
I just want to stay here and gape at those photos. Please, please let me.
WOW! Just FABULOUS! I love Cinnamon.:)
I branched out and tried a new cinnamon roll recipe recently and realized how much I like cinnamon rolls! Yours look fantastic!
Wow - I'm drooling over here! I want to try making them from scratch this year too!
I need to make cinnamon rolls again...like very very soon.
Sorry to hear that you found them a little disappointing. I have also still to make my own cinnamon rolls and loving cinnamon too; this just has to happen soon!
those look incredible! Ive only made cinnamon rolls once. But I think I like the idea of being able to bake them in the morning like that. Mine were so time consuming that I would've had to get up at 4 am to have them for breakfast LOL
Post a Comment